The first step is to boil the eggs. I typically boil the eggs the night before, or at least several hours before serving, to ensure that the eggs can cool properly. If you start to peel them before they have completely cooled, they will be much more difficult to peel.
Next, peel the eggs. After many failed attempts of peeling eggs, I finally have a system down! Make sure the eggs are completely cooled. You can do this by soaking them in cold water or an ice bath. Once the eggs are cooled, smack the egg on a hard surface on all sides, then gently start to peel. Run cold water over the egg while you are peeling, to remove any shell fragments.
Cut the eggs in half, and gently pop the yolk out into a separate bowl. Don't worry...if a few of the eggs rip in the process, you can use them to taste test later.
Using a immersion blender or food processor, blend the egg yolks into a smooth consistency. You can also use a fork if you don't have an immersion blender, but it will take longer to get rid of the lumps.
Add the mayo, mustard, sweet pickle juice, salt and pepper. * I like to add by the spoonful. If you put the full measurement in at once, it may be too runny. Add as you go, until you reach your desired consistency.
Fill each egg with the yolk mixture. I usually do this with a spoon, but you can also use a piping bag/sandwich bag.
Sprinkle with paprika, and enjoy!